An Amphibious Being: How Maritime Surveying Reshaped Darwin's Approach to Natural History.
نویسنده
چکیده
This essay argues that Charles Darwin's distinctive approach to studying distribution and diversity was shaped by his face-to-face interactions with maritime surveyors during the voyage of H.M.S. Beagle (1831-1836). Introducing their hydrographic surveying methods into natural history enabled him to compare fossil and living marine organisms, to compare sedimentary rocks to present-day marine sediments, and to compare landscapes to submarine topology, thereby realizing Charles Lyell's fanciful ambition for a superior form of geology that might be practiced by an "amphibious being." Darwin's theories of continental uplift, coral reef formation, and the origin of species all depended on his amphibious natural history. This essay contributes to our understanding of theorizing in nineteenth-century natural history by illustrating that specific techniques of observing and collecting could themselves help to generate a particular theoretical orientation and, indeed, that such practical experiences were a more proximate source of Darwin's "Humboldtian" interest in distribution and diversity than Alexander von Humboldt's writings themselves. Darwin's debt to the hydrographers became obscured in two ways: through the "funneling" of credit produced by single-authorship publication in natural history and the "telescoping" of memory by which Darwin's new theories made him recall his former researches as though he had originally undertaken them for the very purpose of producing the later theory.
منابع مشابه
Action Stations! 100 years of trauma care on maritime and amphibious operations in the Royal Navy.
Over the past century trauma care within the Royal Navy (RN) has evolved; wartime experiences and military medical research have combined to allow significant improvement in the care of casualties. This article describes the key maritime and amphibious operations that have seen the Royal Navy Medical Service (RNMS) deliver high levels of support to wherever the Naval Service has deployed in the...
متن کاملBack to The Origin
value, Darwinian evolution is no different from the other epistemological entities mentioned above, in that one can fully understand evolution without ever having read a single line of Darwin's own writings. This is because what Darwin laid out as a theory has become superseded by the empirical confirmation and theoretical expansion of the concept of evolution — in particular, its mathematical ...
متن کاملCharles Darwin's debt to Malthus and Edward Blyth.
The traditional view of Darwin's development of the theory of natural selection is that Darwin was inspired to formulate his theory by reading Mathus' Essay on Population. 1 According to a different notion, Darwin overemphasized his debt to Mathus regarding natural selection in order to hide the impact of other writers, in particular Edward Blyth, on his own thinking. 2 The purpose of this pape...
متن کاملEstimation of Reshaped Profile of Berm Breakwaters Using Experimental Data
A reshaping berm breakwater is a type of rubble mound breakwater in which, its seaward slope is allowed to reshape under wave attacks. There are some key parameters in the reshaped seaward profiles, which can schematize the reshaped profile of a berm breakwater. A total of 412 test results was used directly to cover the impact of sea state conditions and structural parameters on these reshaping...
متن کاملA time to remember. The autobiography of a chemist
therefore indirectly influenced Darwin himself. Apart from any connexion with Darwin, this essay is important as the most recent study of this Italian geologist, a distinguished scientist in his own right. Pancaldi clearly outlines Brocchi's work and opinions, and his approach to such thinkers as Lamarck and Bonnet. Especially relevant is the basic incompatibility noted by Brocchi between the c...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
- Isis; an international review devoted to the history of science and its cultural influences
دوره 107 2 شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2016